A Heart-to-Heart on Contact-Based & Reference-Based Recruitment

Let’s be brutally honest, informal hiring is that relative you complain about loudly at home but still invite to every family function because… koi option hi nahi hai.

Employers talk about it in two voices: Public voice: “Referrals improve cultural fit, reduce hiring costs, and enhance retention.” Private voice: “Bas yaar… hope this one doesn’t crash-land like the last one.”

Here’s the real story — both sides of it, without sugarcoating.

________________________________________

Why Employers Secretly Love Informal Hiring

1️. It’s Fast - like India-speed fast

HR says, “We need someone in two weeks.” Someone in the room says, “Mera ek Banda hai…” And the CV arrives before the sentence finishes.

In an era where job portals give you 1,200 irrelevant profiles titled “Fresher — 12 years experience,” referrals feel like oxygen. ________________________________________

2️. It Feels Safe

You’re not hiring a stranger. You’re hiring someone vouched for by another employee. It feels less risky — even though the reality may not match the emotion.

________________________________________

3️. Zero Marketing, Zero Drama

No job ads, no consultants, no campus tours, no mass interviews. Half the time, you don’t even write a JD. You say one line, and the “network” delivers.

________________________________________

4️. Cost? Which cost?

Except for the recruiter’s BP medication… it’s almost free.

________________________________________

Why Employers Secretly Dread Informal Hiring; And now the part nobody admits in LinkedIn posts.

1️. “Homogeneity Syndrome” — Everyone Starts Looking Like Everyone

You hire through X. X refers someone who talks like X. Who then refers someone who thinks like X.

Suddenly your company becomes an echo chamber, not a talent pool. Diversity? Innovation? Fresh thinking? All on ventilator.

________________________________________

2️. The “Favor Chain” Nightmare

Sometimes referrals work. Sometimes they backfire so gloriously that even HR starts praying.

Worst case: The referred candidate performs badly. But the referrer keeps defending them like family court lawyer.

Now you have: • a poor hire, • a politically sensitive situation, • and an HR headache that could be treated as a medical condition.

________________________________________

3️. Nepotism - The Dark Ghost Everyone Pretends Doesn’t Exist

Let’s not be naïve. People push their:

• cousins

• neighbours

• cricket teammates

• tuition friends

• “beta of my close friend”

• and that famous line: “Woh mere uncle ka talent hai.”

And employers suffer silently because rejecting such candidates creates social earthquakes.

________________________________________

4️. Performance Issues Become Political Issues

If a random hire underperforms, you take action. If a referral underperforms… a WhatsApp group, three managers, and HR all start discussing “impact and sensitivity”. Performance management goes from a process to a diplomatic mission.

________________________________________

5️. Bias — Both Ways

Sometimes you over-trust referrals. Sometimes you distrust them simply because they are referrals. Both biases are equally dangerous.

________________________________________

6️. The Emotional Toll

Employers say this quietly but truthfully: “When a referral hire fails, it feels personal.”

Because your employee’s reputation is linked. Your manager’s judgment is questioned.

Your recruitment team feels undermined. It’s not just a bad hire — it’s a bad message.

________________________________________

And Yet… Employers Still Do It

Why? Because every other channel has disappointed them:

❌ Newspaper ads → attract 80% irrelevant CVs

❌ Job portals → flooding, not filtering

❌ HR consultants → same CVs sent with 7 different logos

❌ Campus recruitment → nice photos, weak skills

❌ Walk-ins → lottery tickets disguised as resumes

So employers pick the least painful option — even if they hate it.

________________________________________

The Real Truth?

Informal hiring is neither good nor bad. It’s a symptom of a broken recruitment ecosystem. Employers depend on it not because they want to, but because they don’t have anything better.

And until the talent pipeline improves — through better education, better internships, better skill-building, better employer–academia linkages — referral hiring will continue to be the “necessary evil” nobody likes to admit they rely on.

________________________________________

A Final Heart-to-Heart Line

“Informal hiring is like using jugaad — it works, but everyone knows it’s not the future.”